Is it Dogma that Adam and Eve existed?

Recently, Catholic philosopher Tyler McNabb stated:

Or if the link won’t work, Dr. McNabb states:

Inerrant according to genre. Gen 1-11 isn’t a historical genre but mytho-history. The point of the flood is to teach us about the theological truth that God can’t wipe out evil by external force. The problem is in humans, even the righteous. It’s a change of heart that’s needed

This is interesting for Catholics because they also have other Catholics that claim this view is heresy:

Answer: No, it is not. Below are nine teachings of the Church regarding the first three chapters of Genesis. These teachings can be found in a document which was issued by the Pontifical Biblical Commission, and confirmed by Pope St. Pius X in 1909. These teachings have been the constant teachings of the Church throughout the centuries, and the Pontifical Biblical Commission expounded them in 1909 as a response to the errors of the Modernists that had developed in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The Modernists were, among other things, denying the reality of Adam and Eve.

Now, you might say, “John, this was before Vatican II, the question is: didn’t Vatican II change all of this?” No, it did not. We can find every single one of these nine teachings of Pope St. Pius X, as expounded by the 1909 Pontifical Biblical Commission, in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) that was published in 1994.

So, here they are, the nine teachings of the Church regarding chapters 1-3 of Genesis, as expounded in the 1909 document from the Pontifical Biblical Commission, followed each time by the paragraphs of the 1994 Catechism that carry the corresponding teachings:

2. The special creation of man; CCC #’s 355-359

3. The creation of woman from man [Eve was created from Adam’s rib — well, the Church doesn’t say that it absolutely happened in exactly that way, but it does teach that woman was created from man in some manner]; CCC #371

4. That all of humanity is descended from an original pair of human beings— Adam and Eve; CCC #’s 54-55, 359-360, 375, 390-392, 402-405, 407, 416-417

5. That Adam and Eve were created in an original state of holiness, justice, and immortality; CCC #’s 374-379, 384, 398, 415-416

https://aleteia.org/2015/04/21/does-the-catholic-church-teach-that-adam-and-eve-are-myths/

The Roman Catholic Church has taught infallibly on the subject of Adam and Eve at the Council of Trent.

Now it is true that the Council only mentioned Adam, and not Eve. But the Council teaches that all men are “born propagated of the seed of Adam,” [Decree On Justification, Chapter III.] and they cannot have been so propagated without Eve. And Sacred Scripture teaches us about both Adam and Eve, in both Testaments. So no one could possibly believe that Adam existed, as an individual historical person, and not also Eve.

“1. If anyone does not confess that the first man, Adam, when he had transgressed the commandment of God in Paradise, immediately lost the sanctity and justice in which he had been constituted, and incurred, through the offense of that type of prevarication, the wrath and indignation of God, and therefore also the death with which God had threatened him beforehand, and with death, captivity under the power of him who thereafter held the empire of death, that is, the Devil; and the whole Adam, through that offense of prevarication, was changed for the worse in body and soul: let him be anathema.” [Decree on Original Sin]

It is not possible to hold two contradictory ideas at the same time: the above dogma and the claim that Adam never existed as an individual historical person. The idea that Adam and Eve represent a number of progenitors of the human race, such that they never existed as two individual persons, is entirely incompatible with the required belief that “the first man, Adam…transgressed the commandment of God….”

Any Catholic who claims that Adam and Eve did not exist as two real historical persons is guilty of heresy.

“2. If anyone asserts that the prevarication of Adam harmed himself alone, and not his posterity; and that the sanctification and justice, received from God, which he lost, he lost for himself alone, and not also for us; or that his defilement, through the sin of disobedience, has transfused only death and the punishment of the body into the whole human race, but not also sin, which is the death of the soul: let him be anathema. For he contradicts the Apostle, who says: “through one man, sin entered into the world, and through sin, death; so also, death was transferred into all men, into all who have sinned.” [Romans 5:12].” [Decree on Original Sin]

The Council of Trent also infallibly taught that the sin of Adam adversely affected the whole human race, in body and soul. So the idea is heretical that some human persons were not descended from Adam and Eve. The dogma is that the whole human race is descended from Adam and Eve, without exception. So the human race consists of Adam, Eve, and their descendants only. Even Jesus, in His human nature, and the sinless Virgin Mary are descendants of Adam and Eve.

https://ronconte.com/2017/04/19/against-modern-heresies-adam-and-eve/

Where is the infallible list of all infallible dogmas?

Leave a comment