In this article, Jimmy and I are going to address the objections of a collaborative youtube channel called Scholastic Lutherans. This channel uploaded video last December on the topic of Presuppositionalism, providing some objections. Here, we respond to the objections … Continue reading Scholastic Lutherans’ Objections to Presuppositionalism
Jimmy Stephens: Van Til means that God is exhaustively personal. God has personality or personhood in a way that is self-contained. By comparison, I’m unipersonal in my personhood where God is tripersonal, remembering that I’m an analogical reflection of God’s … Continue reading Van Til’s Serious Trinitarian Theology
I am having a dialogue in regard to the issue with Unitarianism: TheSire: I think (1) it’s somewhat the most promising route here provided but Neoplatonism probably isn’t correct: http://pushingtheantithesis.blogspot.com/2021/08/islam-neoplatonism-and-concept-of.html Islam, Neoplatonism, and the Concept of an Absolute God (pushingtheantithesis.blogspot.com) … Continue reading Is the Love Argument for the Trinity Refuted?
A Thomist was trying to explain what eternal generation without causation. I asked Jimmy Stephens his comments on the issue: The procession of the Word in God is called generation. In proof whereof we must observe that generation has a … Continue reading Emanationism and Generation
Here are the interesting parts of a conversation about the sufficiency of Natural Law theory apart from the Christian God: Jimmy Stephens: This is going to mean that the powers, the goals, or some relation between the two is intrinsically … Continue reading Natural Law Theory and Autonomy
Jimmy Stephens states: He just makes a bunch of claims without any back-up He repeats a few times over, using different synonyms, that gender is reducibly social construct. Uh, okay, says who? I didn’t watch the full video – it … Continue reading Is God Non-Binary? Dan McClellan’s Failure
Barrel Philosophy: Agaist logical or metaphysical necessitarainism. Cuz if it’s logical necessitatarianism I will have to pull up some logic stuff. (Basically it’s just arguing agaist Timothy Williamson saying S5 implies necessitarianism.) The metaphysical one I can present tho. 1. … Continue reading Necessitarianism: Conceive of the Possibilities
Background: ‘ De re ’ means ‘of, or concerning, a thing’. For example, a de dicto belief is a belief that a bearer of representative content is true, while a de re belief is a belief concerning some thing, that … Continue reading Indexical and the Trinity
Daniel Akande: I think within the context of this specific thread, you are begging the question. You asked why we can’t infer all these other facts from unrelated ones. It’s because those facts are measured in a different way. How … Continue reading Does the Authorial Model have a Fictitious Problem?
Nat: Well, I think that’s false. Communication is a two way street. God’s side of communication can be infallible, but the other side can be perfectly fallible, or even shut down entirely the communication, as an example But you could … Continue reading Communication, Canon, and Unbeliever Knowledge of God
The Council 
You must be logged in to post a comment.